Modes And Their Practical Applications For Improvisation And Composition

September 20, 2010
Steve Kirk Blog Modes In Improvisation And Composition

Click on images for hi-res versions.

Many of you may already know about the traditional modes, and that they are based on the notes of the major scale:



The basic concept, as I see it, is that although the notes remain the same, the tonal center changes with the declaration of each different mode, with each different mode beginning on the next degree of the major scale. But there is one other major issue to consider when changing tonal centers—the intervallic relationship of each scale degree to the tonic changes with each different mode. This is why, in example one, I included not only the intervallic relationship between each note to the previous one as it ascends up the scale, but also the intervallic relationship of each note to its tonal center. And the tonal center is key (pun intended), because otherwise you run the risk of thinking you’re using a mode when you are in fact just using the different degrees of one scale.

Let’s frame it this way: it’s probably better to think about notes in the mode you’re using in terms of their intervallic relationship to the key you’re in than the scale degree you begin upon. To underscore this idea, a good exercise might be to write out the different modes using the same tonal center for each mode, and then identify each interval relative to the root tone:


You guys can do the rest, and then try this exercise with different starting notes as the exercise becomes more comfortable.

Now practice these different modes (with the same root) and begin to use them to improvise (or write something out) over a pedal tone (the root tone of the key you’re in as a sustained note accompaniment, as is common in East Indian music). Here is where you can really begin to hear how the color of the music changes with use of different modes over the same pedal tone. Notice that the only difference between the G Mixolydian scale and the G Dorian scale is the B flat, or minor 3rd, but that makes a huge difference in the sound of the scale against the tonic (as well as the chords that would be derived from this scale change, which I will discuss in my next article). Now, take note that the only difference between the G major (or Ionian) and the G Lydian scale is the C sharp, or augmented 4th. But this makes the difference between the opening line of The Simpsons sounding good or not:


Listen to audio of the "good" version.

Listen to audio of the "yuck" version.


I will continue discussing modes and their practical applications in next week's article. In the mean time, have fun exploring the modal possibilities we’ve looked at so far!


Composer, guitarist and arranger Steve Kirk's music has been featured in film, video games and TV. This includes music for the Disney game version of "The Princess And The Frog", Microsoft Games "Voodoo Vince" , the FarmVille Theme for Zynga Games, and to be released in Spring 2011, Cantina music composed for the Star Wars MMOL game The Other Republic.


printer friendly version

Dorian Mode question...

By: Jamie V (not verified)

Don't know if it's a miss print or not, but shouldn't the Dorian mode have a Minor 2nd instead of a Major 2nd for the second interval?

Thanks,
JV

Mon, 2010-09-20 14:42

Dorian Mode

By: skirk

Hi Jamie-

In answer to your question, no, the Dorian mode naturally occurs from D to D on the white keys of the piano, which would make the 2nd degree of the scale an E; a major 2nd.

Check out my music example of a simple Dorian melody by going to this link:

http://www.gearwire.com/strategiesharmonizingpanmodalmelodies-stevekirkblog.html

You have a graphic and sound example of an E Dorian melody- E F# G A B C# D E -essentially a natural minor scale with a Major 6th instead of a Minor 6th.

Best,

Steve

Mon, 2010-09-20 15:18

Oh wait

By: skirk

Oh wait, now I see what you're saying- the interval between the 2nd and 3rd degree of the dorian mode should be a minor 2nd!! A miss-print. Whoops! I'll get right on that!

Sorry!

-Steve

Mon, 2010-09-20 15:23

typo

By: skirk

By the way Jamie, thanks for catching that!

Mon, 2010-09-20 15:32

No Problem!

By: Jamie V (not verified)

I was just making sure that I wasn't going crazy.

Tue, 2010-09-21 14:54

OK, it's fixed now

By: skirk

Of course then I had to re-check the other intervals to make sure there were no other typos, but everything should be correct now.

Mon, 2010-09-20 15:56

Application of modes

By: Anonymous Cow (not verified)

When I was studying jazz guitar in Vienna, one of the problems was, that the modes were all based on the key of C Major. Although I understood it theoretically, soundwise it was all C Major for me.

It would have been much better for my hearing to work with a tonal center. I also think it would be better to approach scales and modes on the guitar from an intervallic perspective. As a guitarist I see the fretboard too much in the context of fingerings.

This is still an interesting topic for me. After all this years, it seems I am a beginner (again) :)

Wed, 2010-09-22 08:07

Modes in C

By: skirk

Yes, it seems to me that if you don't try transposing modes into different keys, than it's hard to hear it as anything but one big continuous major scale, and looking at the relationship of each interval to the tonic of each mode is critical to hearing that mode in it's proper context. The same as in a major or minor scale, a melody created in any mode should gravitate around and eventually resolve to it's tonic for the mode to have a clear identity.

Fri, 2010-09-24 03:45

VKTokusILDcaMSouf

By: Dolley (not verified)

That's the best asnewr of all time! JMHO

Sat, 2011-08-20 20:15

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • No HTML tags allowed
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Please type in the lowercase letters that are shown in the image above.
I need awesome gear... I'd like a free gear catalog!
My opinion is awesome. I'd like to take a gear survey